Carpe Cookie

A grade-A cookie lover's account of the best – and sometimes worst – cookies around.

Navigation Menu

Cookie Salon #2: Peanut Butter*

Posted by on Apr 3, 2011 in Peanut Butter, Cookie Salon | 0 comments

Peanut Butter* Cookie Salon

(What is a cookie salon?)

Date: March 15, 2011

Attendees: Sarah V.B., Brooke M., Giovanna Z., Beth S., Joanna M.

*The theme was actually “Nut Butter/Nut Flour, but in the end it was peanut butter dominated affair, with only 2 of the 9  cookie being non peanut butter (almond flour).

Top row – from left

• No flour peanut butter – Sarah
Grand Central Bakery Cookbook (with chocolate chips)- Sarah
• Grand Central Bakery Cookbook (w/o cc) – Sarah
Food and Style Sienese Almond Cookie – Beth
New Seasons Grocery Store (purchased from in-house bakery) – Brooke

Read More

Cookie Salon

Posted by on Mar 24, 2011 in Oatmeal, Cookie Salon | 0 comments

COOKIE SALON

Friends, I have fulfilled a New Year’s resolution.  Since the beginning of this year, I started up  a “cookie salon” with a handful of friends and my sister (who is also a friend, btw).

What is a Cookie Salon?” you might ask.

From Wikipedia:

A salon is a gathering of people under the roof of an inspiring host, held partly to amuse one another and partly to refine taste and increase their knowledge of the participants through conversation. These gatherings often consciously followed Horace’s definition of the aims of poetry, “either to please or to educate” (“aut delectare aut prodesse est”). Salons, commonly associated with French literary and philosophical movements of the 17th century and 18th centuries, were carried on until quite recently, in urban settings, among like-minded people.

Mostly, it’s an excuse to eat cookies and feel like we’re doing something important, intellectual and artistic.

We’re pretty much just making it up as we go along – no hard and fast rules have been set. It should be stressed that the meeting’s featured cookies are, indeed, included as “participants.”  In other words, in keeping with the above conversation,  we aim to increase our knowledge of the participants (i.e., cookies and one another) through conversation.

We’re meeting approximately once a month, choosing a different theme each time. So far we’ve had:

1) Oatmeal Salon
2) Nut Butter/Nut Flour Salon

upcoming salon: New York Times Chocolate Chip Cookie

The idea is to make a cookie (a couple of  overachievers in the group have made 3-5 different cookies per salon) relating to the chosen theme and then pack a dozen or so in a tin and meet a neighborhood pub where they don’t seem to pay much attention to six women sitting at a mini-hoffbrau table with an abnormal amount of (not the pub’s) cookies spread out before them. And then to simultaneously taste each cookie, one-by-one, discussing and pontificating as we go.  This is what it basically is:  cookie monsters geeking out on cookies the way that only cookie monsters who also bake (and not just eat) cookies are able to do.

Like, we’ll talk about what happens when you use baking powder and not soda, how less flour and more oats make a chewier cookie, etc.  Or if we like golden raisins better than Thompson. Or apricots better than raisins.  Or how processed peanut butter behaves in comparison to natural peanut butter. Or how the Gourmet Cookbook recipe stacks up next to Dorrie Greenspan’s. Important stuff like that.

I am now posting photos and notes from Oatmeal Salon and Nut Butter/Nut Flour Salon -and will post a report for each ensuing salon.

Membership is open. No annual dues required (apart from bringing cookies to the table.  Literally.)

Inquire within for more details.

Read More

OMG Chocolate Chip at Alma

Posted by on Mar 17, 2011 in Chocolate Chip | 0 comments

Alma Chocolate
140 NE 28th Ave – Portland
$1.25

OMG Chocolate Chip Cookie:  This is what the bakery calls it. I didn’t just throw that in there ‘cuz I think it’s a slammin’ cookie (I do think it’s a slamming cookie, BTW). Or, because I like to use cute abbreviations for stuff, FYI.  Or because I buy them for my BFF’s, who love CCC’s, and live in PDX.

Like I was sayin’, this is a great chocolate chip cookie and I should have mentioned it sooner.  Portland Monthly Magazine, in fact, just gave it a nod in their recent cc cookie roundup – and although I am not on board with a few that they singled out, I could not agree more about this (kind of) hidden gem at Alma.

Read More

Oatmeal Fig at Bakery Nouveau

Posted by on Mar 7, 2011 in Oatmeal | 0 comments

Bakery Nouveau
4737 California Ave. SW – West Seattle
$1.75

Holy shit, ANOTHER  fantastic oatmeal cookie!  They’re comin’ outta the woodwork lately – breaking new oatmeal ground.  And I am not complaining.

I recently declared that the oatmeal cranberry currant at Common Grounds may be the best one around,  but I spoke too soon. Not that I would EVER turn down the Common Grounds cookie (still a fantastic offering worth going out of your way for) – especially in light of the fact that the one I’m about to lay on you is a 3 hour drive from where I live.

Read More

Chocolate Chip at Common Grounds

Posted by on Feb 26, 2011 in Chocolate Chip | 0 comments

Common Grounds Coffee House
4321 Se Hawthorne Blvd – Portland
$1

Since I just told you about the unexpectedly delicious oatmeal cookie that I found at Common Grounds recently, I thought I may as well stay on topic and tell you about their chocolate chip.

As I mentioned in the oatmeal post, I was alerted by on of my main chipster tipsters that the chocolate chip cookie here is straight up Toll House, super basic and pleasing. No nuts, nothing fancy – just old school, after-school special style. But so far I’ve  bypassed the ccc, honing in on the oatmeal and, on my last visit, was unable to resist taking home a chunk of their homey, unadorned gingerbread – which I did not regret for a split second. It was some top notch G-bread. And if you dig that sort of thing, you need to get some in your mouth, stat. (I drooled a little bit onto my keyboard just thinking about it, if you want to know the truth.)

Read More

Ultrathin and huge Chocolate Chunk at Auntie Em’s Kitchen

Posted by on Feb 18, 2011 in Chocolate Chip | 2 comments

Auntie Em’s Kitchen
4616 Eagle Rock Blvd  – L.A. (Eagle Rock)
$2

It has been said that if you put 10 Jews in a room, you’ll hear 11 different opinions.

I might say the same is true for chocolate chip cookie eaters. In other words, it is a highly divisive topic. Some favor thin and crisp, some swear by thick and doughy. Or thin and chewy. Or thick and biscuity. Some dig walnuts or pecans, others say “hell no” to the nuts. Some ccc bakers misguidedly think they’re doing us a great favor by including butterscotch – or possibly worse – white chocolate chips. Ugh and double ugh. The possibilities are endless – more so than with perhaps any other cookie.

Read More

Oatmeal currant & cranberry at Common Grounds Coffee House

Posted by on Feb 12, 2011 in Oatmeal, Whole grain | 0 comments

Common Grounds Coffee House
4321 Se Hawthorne Blvd – Portland
$1

Note: I owe this find entirely to one of my favorite cookie eaters and tipsters. (I was getting ready to write that the above link has nothing to do with cookies, but I then realized: what in the world could have more to do with cookies than…Santa Claus?   It’s all a big circle game,  my friends.)

Read More

Extra Chocolaty Chocolate Cookie* at Mother’s Bistro & Bar

Posted by on Feb 5, 2011 in Chocolate, Chocolate Chip | 0 comments

Mother’s Bistro & Bar
212 SW Stark St – Portland
$1.50

Not that it should be surprising that you would find a great cookie at Mother’s. I mean, this is a place that is known and loved in Portland for it’s top notch comfort food. Also,  I’m pretty sure a place that calls itself “Mother’s” is legally obliged to provide not just cookies, but super awesome, homemade-y gems like the ones goin’ on here. The thing is, Mother’s is a full-fledged, (quite lovely) sit-down restaurant –  not a bakery, per se – or a coffee shop where you might think to pop in and grab a cookie to go. But you can.  You totally CAN!

Read More

Lemon Meringue Cookie at Proof Bakery

Posted by on Jan 26, 2011 in Meringue, Lemon | 2 comments

Proof Bakery
3156 Glendale Blvd
Los Angeles (Atwater Village)
$2

Before visiting L.A. recently, I had read that a brand new bakery called Proof (opened in December ’10) was making a cookie called a zimsterne. I’d somehow never heard of these, which is surprising because it is a cookie that is completely after my own heart. I have a soft spot for anything almond – particularly almond paste, marzipan or almond flour – the latter being a key player in the zimsterne. Also, I love cinnamon. I was sold – enough so to make the somewhat out-of-the-way drive (from where I was) to Atwater Village (not far from Silverlake).

Read More

Pumpkin Cookie with Brown Sugar Icing at Sweet Life

Posted by on Jan 5, 2011 in Etc., Pumpkin | 0 comments

Sweet Life Patisserie
755 Monroe Street – Eugene, OR
$1.95

Here’s why I love this cookie:

1. It’s made out of pumpkin. There is no good  reason we should be eating pumpkin only from October-December; this is why preservation was invented, friends.  Canned pumpkin is a lovely, lovely thing and I want to eat it in February, June and August as much as I do in November. Pumpkin need not be any more “seasonal” than ketchup or jam. The bakers at Sweet Life understand this fact and therefore grace us with their awesome pumpkin cookie 12 months a year.*  And for that I thank them.

Read More

Cougar Mountain cookie dough

Posted by on Dec 2, 2010 in Etc., Pumpkin | 0 comments

Cougar Mountain Baking Company

Pumpkin Cookie Dough
Your grocer’s refrigerator case – hint: look near the Kozy Shack Pudding!**
$3.50-$3.99-ish/18 oz (apx 18 cookies-worth)

I had oral surgery last week.  I’m not talking about your run of the mill, pansy-ass root canal, friends. This was some serious shit: several (as in, more than a couple) teeth were extracted (by my Chris O’Donnell look-alike periodontist, btw),

Read More

Date Maamoul at Barbur World Foods

Posted by on Nov 22, 2010 in Etc., Shortbread/Sugar Cookies, Fruit | 1 comment

Barbur World Foods
9845 Southwest Barbur Blvd – Portland
$1.50

I’ve been meaning to tell you about this maamoul that I picked up a couple of weeks ago at the in-house bakery of  Barbur World Foods – a specialty grocery store that imports foods internationally –  mainly from the Middle East and Europe.

When I unwrapped the cookie, a warm and deep vanilla scent filled the air.  It actually made me shiver, I’m not lying.  And the very smoothly-ground date filling was kissed with orange blossom water, all of which had soaked into the buttery, shortbread-like crust – making the whole affair  moist, fragrant and sensational.

Really sweet and rich, in a baklava sort of way.

And it was only a buck and half.

Just for future reference.

Read More

Peanut Butter at little t american baker

Posted by on Nov 2, 2010 in Peanut Butter | 0 comments

little t american baker
2600 SE Division – Portland
$1.25

I should tell you straight away that I almost never eat peanut butter cookies. It’s not so much that I hate them, but when it comes time to pick my poison, it’s never my first choice (or even second or third). But being that the pbc is adored by so many fellow cookie-eaters and also being that the entire raison d’etre of Carpe Cookie is to lead you to the golden nuggets in the overcrowded field of mostly mundane cookies, I realized it was time to represent. Represent the pbc, that is.

Read More

Chocolate Chip, Dark Chocolate Chocolate Chip, and Oatmeal Raisin at Levain

Posted by on Oct 24, 2010 in Chocolate, Oatmeal, Chocolate Chip | 2 comments

Levain Bakery
167 West 74th St. – New York City
$4*


A few times over the past few years, I’ve been asked by friends to provide a list of bakeries (i.e.,cookies) worth seeking out while visiting New York City.  Even though (with the exception of one year in the mid-nineties) I have never lived in NYC, I’ve been there a bunch of times.  And I’m sure it comes as no surprise that during these visits, cookie scouting ends up high on my priority list – above, I am simultaneously ashamed and proud to admit, The Guggenheim, MOMA, Broadway performances, shoe shopping, etc.  I will plan entire walking itineraries around strategically-located bakeries; this is how I roll. (OMG: if somebody has not already opened a bakery called “This Is How We Roll”, it needs to happen – stat! Genius.)

Read More

Ginger Molasses at Lovejoy Bakers

Posted by on Oct 15, 2010 in Ginger Molasses | 2 comments

Lovejoy Bakers
939 NW 10th Ave – Portland
$1.75

I know, right?  Another ginger molasses cookie.  What can I say?  I can’t help myself.

I’m not saying I like this less or more than the two other Portland ginger molasseses I’ve talked about, and if asked to chose a favorite between the PearlCrema and this version, I would be hard pressed.   I simply enjoy and appreciate it as a more than satisfactory variation on one of my favorite kinds of cookie.

Read More